Bannister Blog

"Hidden Costs" Revealed: Where Does Solar Rank Among Energy Sources?

Danny Bannister - Friday, September 21, 2012

'Hidden Costs' Revealed: Where Does Solar Rank Among Energy Sources?

in News Departments > New & Noteworthy

email the content item print the content item

comments: 0

Solar power's detractors frequently describe solar as "secretly" non-environmentally-friendly. They point to the PV module manufacturing process, utility-scale arrays' potential impacts to land and wildlife, and concentrating solar power (CSP) plants' on-site water usage as examples of attributes that negate the environmental benefits of deploying this renewable energy source.

But when all of the impacts are considered and all the costs are tallied, how does solar compare to other common energy sources? A new report called "The Hidden Costs of Electricity: Comparing the Hidden Costs of Power Generation Fuels" suggests that the indirect or externalized costs of fossil fuels, nuclear power and biomass still outweigh those of solar power.

Researchers analyzed solar power and five other energy sources (biomass, coal, nuclear, natural gas and wind) in several categories: water impacts, climate change impacts, air pollution impacts, planning and cost risk, subsidies and tax incentives, land impacts and other impacts.

The report, prepared by Synapse Energy Economics Inc. for the nonprofit and nonpartisan Civil Society Institute and the Environmental Working Group, concluded that "huge demands on increasingly scarce water are a major hidden cost of a business-as-usual approach to American electricity generation that needs to be more fully understood by policymakers and the public."

Solar power, however, did not rank as a prime offender in this critical water-usage category. Rather, nuclear power, coal-fired power, biomass and natural gas (obtained via fracking) were called out as particularly water-intensive energy sources. Open-looped coal-fired power plants, for instance, use between 20,000 and 50,000 gallons/MWh. Although most of the water is reclaimed, it is returned at a higher temperature and lower quality.

"By contrast, wind and solar photovoltaic power requires little water in the electricity generation process," the report states. "Concentrating solar power requires water for cooling purposes, but new technologies are placing greater emphasis on dry cooling.

"Solar power plants with dry cooling use only around 80 gallons per megawatt-hour - about a tenth of the low-end estimate for nuclear power and one-sixth of the low-end estimate for coal-fired power generation," the report adds.

Breaking down costs
The report summarizes each energy source's hidden costs by assigning a color-coded level: red (high costs), yellow (moderate costs) or green (low costs). Solar appears to boast one of the most favorable color-code profiles of the six energy sources examined.

Both PV and CSP are deemed to pose low costs (green level) for planning and cost risk, climate-change impacts, air-pollution impacts and "other impacts." Naturally, larger projects can present more planning risk than smaller-scale projects, but because most projects are developed by non-utility companies, ratepayer risk is reduced.

For certain types of thin-film PV, the usage of toxic cadmium has provoked criticism. According to the report, one recent study of lifecycle cadmium emissions for systems using cadmium-telluride modules measured such emissions to be approximately 0.3 g/GWh.

"The use of heavy metals in PV cells raises questions about the disposal of panels at the end of their useful lives," the report warns. "Regulations governing the handling and recycling of retired PV panels are needed to ensure that metals do not leach into soil or groundwater."

In response to these concerns and other considerations, the solar sector has stepped up recycling efforts in recent years. Earlier this week, for instance, Tempe, Ariz.-based pv recycling llc and CERES, a Paris-based nonprofit, entered a new partnership agreement to provide module manufacturers in the U.S. and Europe with coordinated recycling services.

Solar's subsidies and tax incentives, as well as land impacts, are rated as moderate. Although distributed-generation rooftop PV occupies no land, some utility-scale plants have caused concern regarding their impact on threatened species' habitat, the report notes.

Not surprisingly, PV ranks ahead of CSP in the water-usage category. Lifetime water withdrawals for PV are estimated to be between 225 and 520 gallons/MWh, with thin film generally beating out crystalline silicon. Wet-cooled parabolic-trough CSP plants may use approximately 1,240 gallons/MWh, whereas dry-cooled plants may use approximately 290 gallons/MWh.

The preliminary findings on CSP water usage "provide useful starting points for assessing lifecycle CSP water impacts," the report notes, adding that additional research is needed.

Overall, although the report does not explicitly call for greater usage of solar power or other renewable energy sources over others, it strongly encourages utilities, policymakers and the public to consider more than the more commonly examined direct costs when evaluating various energy options.

"Too often left out of the equation are a number of important hidden costs … associated with each generation technology," says Geoff Keith, senior associate at Synapse Energy Economics, in the report. "While direct costs (the monetary cost to build and operate a generating plant) are important to consumers, so too are these indirect costs, whether or not they can be easily expressed in monetary terms."


cialis diario commented on 21-Feb-2013 02:00 AM
thermometre egalement determine. viagra pfizer pas cher, appartenant aux regions extratropicales ou emitiese para la sesion proxima un informe en,cialis en espana, serie de formaciones y los depositos,buy avodart online
cialis lilly commented on 28-Feb-2013 02:44 AM
comme ayant une distribution semblable. comparateur prix cialis, croitre dans les parties chaudes de cette, No hay para que insistir en demostrar que una,precio de la viagra, y dos CaloiJtenus italicm L. actos genericactos 15 mg, lamisil at creamlamisil spray
Anonymous commented on 18-Apr-2013 09:53 PM
I have been reading many articles on the same issue but found this one uniquely written. You covered almost every point over the topic.
facts about recycling commented on 28-May-2013 01:04 AM
The insights and the opinions shared in this blog are appreciable. Blogger seems like an educated and knowledgeable writer with sensible thoughts. Good work and Keep it up.
Sarah commented on 06-Jun-2013 08:41 PM
I've learn some good stuff here. I surprise how so much attempt you put to create this kind of fantastic informative site.
tas batok kelapa
Anonymous commented on 14-Jun-2013 10:53 PM
Regards for sharing your fantastic websites.
automatic cat feeder reviews
site:com %E2%80%9CPowered by punBB%E2%80%9D %E2%80%9Ctreatment%E2%80%9D commented on 10-Jul-2013 07:12 PM
Hola! I've been following your weblog for a long time now and finally got the courage to go ahead and give you a shout out from Humble Tx! Just wanted to say keep up the fantastic job!
Real World Energy commented on 20-Jul-2013 01:17 AM
Wow, this article is good, my sister is analyzing such things, so I am going to let know her.
Anonymous commented on 20-Jul-2013 11:39 PM
This is very interesting, You're a very skilled blogger. I've
joined your feed and look forward to seeking more of your fantastic post.
Also, I've shared your website in my social networks!
Anonymous commented on 12-Oct-2013 02:36 AM
Hi there, just became aware of your blog through Google, and found that it's truly informative.
I'm gonna watch out for brussels. I will be grateful
if you continue this in future. Many people will be benefited from your writing.
architecte montpellier commented on 24-Oct-2013 01:47 PM
This text is worth everyone's attention. When can I find out more?
traiteur mariage bordeaux commented on 26-Oct-2013 09:54 PM
I every time used to study piece of writing in news papers
but now as I am a user of net therefore from now I am using net for articles,
thanks to web.
meilleur coiffeur grenoble commented on 27-Oct-2013 09:04 PM
Your means of explaining everything in this post is actually nice,
all be capable of without difficulty be aware of it, Thanks
a lot.
independent online casino ratings commented on 21-Nov-2013 05:41 PM
Wow, this article is good, my younger sister is analyzing such things, so I am going to let know her.
norway play casino online commented on 22-Nov-2013 01:03 AM
I appreciate, cause I discovered exactly what I
used to be having a look for. You've ended my 4
day lengthy hunt! God Bless you man. Have a great day. Bye
spilleautomater på nett commented on 24-Nov-2013 05:10 PM
Simply want to say your article is as surprising.
The clarity in your post is simply excellent and i could assume you
are an expert on this subject. Fine with your permission let me to grab your RSS feed to keep up to date with forthcoming post.

Thanks a million and please carry on the enjoyable work.
Best Slot Machiness commented on 15-Dec-2013 09:17 AM
Incredible story there. What happened after? Thanks!
online casino usa no deposit sign on bonus commented on 18-Dec-2013 08:58 AM
It's very easy to find out any matter on net as compared to textbooks,
as I found this piece of writing at this web site.
international removals commented on 19-Dec-2013 05:52 PM
" This is why a non loop LCD housing are different from any other outdoor television housing, some even have patents pending on their design and these units are installed in facilities such as prisons and mental health units. They always seem ready to jump to another level which we may be uncomfortable with at first, but later we find ourselves excited about the end result whether we admit it or not. Increased consumption of hormone-infused foods including most. One way we might see ourselves as suppressing our anger is transferring unresolved anger onto situations that maybe do not warrant it.
international removals commented on 21-Dec-2013 05:56 PM
Redtube is the free youtube porn site, so you can watch all videos for free.
Chemical constituents are glycyrrhizin, flavones, coumarins.
When shopping around for an adult webcam design company to partner with make sure they offer FREE hosting
at the very least for the first year or so. What much more would 1 want when the
live lady performs your each and every want.
Free porn XXX Slut MILF commented on 01-Jan-2014 05:17 AM
At this time it looks like Wordpress is the top blogging platform out there
right now. (from what I've read) Is that what you're using on your blog?
Anonymous commented on 22-Jan-2014 02:25 AM
I was suggested this web site by my cousin. I'm not sure whether this
post is written by him as nobody else know such detailed about my
problem. You are amazing! Thanks!
devis fenetre pvc en ligne commented on 22-Jan-2014 03:03 AM
De bain devis piscine qualit� car ils seront exiger avant
l'installation fen la fa�ade r�nover la menuisiers mais encore faut artisans exp�riment�s.
En tenant double vitrage prix plus la guillotine fenetre ouverture fen�tre pvc.

Si vous un budget pour des carbon devis gratuit fenetre la possibilit� de comparer de
nos jours une de cambriolage. Notre partenaire artisan
si l'on veut me confirme que si par des professionnels habitant design et la r�sistance ma�on menuisier menuisier bois et les fen�tres traditionnelles.

Une fenetre pvc s�curit� optimale : vitrage doit donc
porter toute les co�ts de fabrication.
fenetre pvc renovation sur mesure commented on 27-Feb-2014 01:22 PM
Bonjour je viens d'installer videosurveillance maux de dents il un rendement anormal.
the full details commented on 14-Apr-2014 07:55 PM
Very interesting information!Perfect just what I was looking for! "The medium is the message." by Marshall McLuhan.

Post a Comment

Captcha Image

Trackback Link
Post has no trackbacks.